From: Frank Ketchum on
How do you decide when you have a tie after a match? I thought I read
somewhere that you hold a putt off on the putting green to settle up. If
so, how does it work? A neutral party picks the hole and the starting
point? New hole and starting point each time?

I am asking because I play in a couple friendly tournaments with some
friends and we need a better way to settle tie matches.


From: kenpitts on
On Apr 21, 7:25 pm, "Frank Ketchum" <nos...(a)thanksanyway.fu> wrote:
> How do you decide when you have a tie after a match?  I thought I read
> somewhere that you hold a putt off on the putting green to settle up.  If
> so, how does it work?  A neutral party picks the hole and the starting
> point?  New hole and starting point each time?
>
> I am asking because I play in a couple friendly tournaments with some
> friends and we need a better way to settle tie matches.

I lost two playoffs at RSG Atlanta on putt offs, oh one in Memphis
also. You start playing hole on the practice green until one guy has
the lower score. Sudden death. In Atlanta the second time, (-1) 71 was
not good enough to avoid the putt-off.

Ken
From: kenpitts on
On Apr 21, 10:47 pm, "R&B" <none_of_your_busin...(a)all.com> wrote:
> On 2010-04-21 20:25:26 -0400, Frank Ketchum said:
>
> > How do you decide when you have a tie after a match?  I thought I read
> > somewhere that you hold a putt off on the putting green to settle up.  
> > If so, how does it work?  A neutral party picks the hole and the
> > starting point?  New hole and starting point each time?
>
> > I am asking because I play in a couple friendly tournaments with some
> > friends and we need a better way to settle tie matches.
>
> At RSG-ATLANTA, the organizer (me) picked the routing of holes and the
> starting point.  It wasn't sudden death.  As I recall, there was a
> three-hole routing.  If tied after that, it went to sudden death.
>
> Same deal when I won at RSG-MEMPHIS in '99.  That's where I got the
> idea.  I stole it from tunamint organizer Joe Cartpath.  (Hey, whatever
> happened to him, anyway?)
>
> Randy

I thought it was sudden death. Oh well. I was 0 for 3 in these
things.

Ken
From: Paul Schmitz-Josten on
Frank Ketchum in <N7mAn.90345$kj3.6796(a)newsfe08.iad>:

>> If unable to continue play, there is always the "scorecard playoff."
>
>What would that be? Go back over the card and see who one the first hole
>that wasn't halved?

First of all, I think that the RSG events are stroke play and not match
play. In match play, there is hardly another option than to continue
playing (even if it is on a putting green) or to toss the dice.

Scorecard playoff in stroke play:
-----------------------------------------
The easy way:
Compare the # of (net) strokes (or Stableford points) in the
last 9 (if even: 6, 3, 1) holes played.

The difficult way (usually with the help of a computer):
Select the holes with the stroke indices 1, 18, 3, 16, 5, 14, 7, 12, 9
and compare the (net) strokes or Stableford points.
In case of even results, take the holes with SIs 1, 18, 3, 16, 5, 14,
then SIs 1, 18, 3 and at last the SI 1 hole.

Ciao,

Paul
From: John van der Pflum on
On Wed, 21 Apr 2010 20:25:26 -0400, "Frank Ketchum"
<nospam(a)thanksanyway.fu> wrote:

>How do you decide when you have a tie after a match? I thought I read
>somewhere that you hold a putt off on the putting green to settle up. If
>so, how does it work? A neutral party picks the hole and the starting
>point? New hole and starting point each time?
>
>I am asking because I play in a couple friendly tournaments with some
>friends and we need a better way to settle tie matches.

If you are just talking about a regular match during the week there is
no tie breaker. The match is just halved and no one wins or loses.

To determine the championship for my event I do have a tie breaker,
though. My event is Modified Stableford scoring. There are a couple
of different levels of tie breakers but they all involve a "scorecard"
playoff. The final tiebreaker is arm wrestling.
--
jvdp
Hey Annika, you'll never hold these:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/rockpyle/3940732311/

http://www.rsgcincinnati.com
 |  Next  |  Last
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5
Prev: Weeds on greens?
Next: shot of the day